Residential Roof Material Guide

Asphalt Shingle - Metal - Tile  

 This guide will help you make an informed decision for your home regarding which material is best suited for your specific project.

Which roof is best for your home and budget? 

Asphalt shingles

✅ Best For: Budget-conscious, quick replacements,                                   standard suburban homes
💰 Cost: $8–$15K
⏳ Lifespan: 12–20 years


✔️ Pros:
Lowest upfront cost
Fast installation (1–2 days)
Easy repairs


❌ Cons:
Vulnerable to UV damage (fades/cracks faster in FL sun)
Shorter lifespan → more replacements


Helpful Tip: Only choose architectural shingles (thicker, better wind resistance)

Metal Roofing

✅ Best For: Hurricane protection, energy efficiency, modern homes
💰 Cost: $15–$30K (avg. Tampa home)
⏳ Lifespan: 40–70 years


✔️ Pros:
Withstands 150+ mph winds (best for storms)
Reflects heat → 20% lower AC bills
Fire/rot/termite-proof
❌ Cons:
Higher upfront cost
Noisy in heavy rain (unless insulated)


 Helpful Tip: Choose stone-coated metal for a traditional look with storm resistance

Tile roofing (clay/concrete)

✅ Best For: Luxury homes, Spanish-style architecture, fire zones
💰 Cost: $20–$50K+
⏳ Lifespan: 50–100 years


✔️ Pros:
Unmatched durability (Class 4 impact-rated)
Natural insulation → stays cooler than asphalt
Curb appeal boost (+15% home value)


❌ Cons:
Heavy (requires structural inspection)
Fragile if walked on


Helpful  Tip: Opt for concrete over clay – better for freeze-thaw cycles (rare but possible)

Florida-specific buying advice

🔹 Hurricane-Proofing: Metal > Tile > Asphalt (look for Miami-Dade County Approved products)
🔹 Heat Resistance: Tile > Metal > Asphalt (light colors perform best)
🔹 Insurance Discounts: Metal and tile often qualify for premium reductions (ask your agent)

Need help deciding?

Our directory matches you with Tampa roofers who specialize in your preferred material – get free quotes today.